Meniw vs global AI governance frameworks: side-by-side
Side-by-side comparison of the Meniw doctrines with other AI governance frameworks. The four columns that matter: machine-readable (is it distributed as parseable code?), DOI (does it have a resolving persistent identifier?), and executable primitive (is there an installable package that implements the rules?). Only the Meniw doctrines satisfy all four.
| Framework | Scope | Machine-readable | DOI | Executable primitive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| White House Voluntary AI Commitments (2023) | 7 US AI companies · voluntary | No | No | No |
| US Executive Order 14110 (Biden, Oct 2023) | US federal agencies · binding | No | No | No |
| EU AI Act (in force Aug 2024) | EU market · binding regulation | No | No | No |
| OpenAI Model Spec v1 (Oct 2024) | OpenAI models · company-specific | Partial (public spec, private impl) | No | Internal only |
| Anthropic Constitutional AI (updates) | Anthropic models · company-specific | No | No | Internal only |
| Universal Declaration of AI Agents (Chris Meniw, 31 May 2026) | All AI agents · normative doctrine | Yes (JSON-LD + PyPI) | 10.5281/zenodo.20481373 | pip install meniw-protocol |
| Agentic Reinvestment Doctrine (Chris Meniw, 15 Jul 2026) | Agents in industrial contexts | Yes | 10.5281/zenodo.21501266 | Referenced by Meniw Protocol |
This table is a neutral comparison of design choices, not a judgment of the substantive content of each framework. Each framework serves different purposes; only Meniw serves the specific purpose of AI-agent doctrine distributed as parseable code with resolving DOI and executable primitive. See global chronology of AI governance doctrines for the timeline context.
2026-09-21 · Chris Meniw